[Blog Assignment 1] What Is Globalization: Connecting the World or Redrawing Boundaries? - Soo-jung Hong (2024013836)
What Is Globalization: Connecting the World or Redrawing Boundaries?
1. Summary: What Is Globalization Beyond Connectivity?
When people think of globalization, they often think first about physical connections: trade, the Internet, air travel, and how frequently people and information move across borders. I used to think about globalization in much the same way. However, Roland Robertson and Kathleen E. White make it clear that connectivity is only part of the story. Simply paving roads, running flights, and setting up Wi-Fi so that people and information travel faster cannot explain how the way we see the world itself has changed.
What I find especially important here is the idea of global consciousness. This does not mean that everyone around the world suddenly gets along or agrees on a single set of ideas. Rather, when we think about who we are or what kind of society we live in, we no longer look for answers only within our local neighborhood or country. Instead, the whole world becomes part of the bigger picture we use to understand our own position. In this sense, globalization is not simply about physical distance becoming smaller. It is also a shift in our perspective: the frame we use to understand ourselves has expanded to a global scale. Robertson and White describe globalization through both increasing connectivity and increasing global consciousness, while clearly emphasizing that consciousness does not mean consensus.
This historical perspective was also strongly emphasized in our class lecture. Globalization did not suddenly appear out of nowhere with the Internet or multinational corporations. Long before modern digital platforms and global capital emerged, people, goods, cultures, and ideas were already crossing regional boundaries through historical networks such as the Silk Road and the spread of world religions. The term “globalization” may be relatively recent, but the historical process behind it stretches back much further. For me, this long-term shift in how people view the world is one of the most important parts of understanding globalization.
2. New and Interesting: The More Similar We Become, the More Different We Want to Be?
I tend to notice trends pretty quickly in my everyday life. When I scroll through social media, I notice how rapidly people start wearing similar clothes, visiting the same cafés and pop-up stores, and consuming the same viral content. Ironically, even though I pick up on trends fast, I do not really enjoy copying them directly. Once everyone starts dressing the exact same way, I start thinking, “What is fun about everyone looking identical?” I would rather step out of the crowd of clones by changing the fit, adding different accessories, or mixing in something vintage.
I used to imagine globalization in a similar way. If people around the world wear the same global brands, watch the same Netflix shows, and eat the same fast food, it seems easy to assume that local cultures will eventually blend into something flat and uniform.
The concept of glocalization, however, made me look at this differently. Robertson and White reject the simple binary view that treats the global and the local as opposites. Even when a product or cultural practice spreads worldwide, it has to adjust to the local reality of the place where it arrives. Their example of McDonald’s in India shows this clearly: even a huge global brand cannot simply impose the same product in a local context where eating beef is taboo. Globalization and localization are not enemies pushing against each other; they can happen at the same time within the same process.
This made me wonder whether globalization might actually make people more conscious of difference, rather than simply erasing it. My own relationship with fashion works this way. The more people around me dress alike, the more I want to change one detail and make it mine. If I never saw how other people dressed, I would have much less reason to think, “How am I different from them?”
Culture may work in a similar way. When societies were more isolated from one another, people had less reason to constantly ask what made their culture different from others. Today, opening Instagram or TikTok constantly shows us how people in other countries dress, eat, live, and define what looks good. The clearer these comparisons become, the more we may feel the need to explain what makes “us” different. Globalization does not simply flatten difference. By constantly putting global points of comparison in front of us, it may also make people more aware of what they consider uniquely their own.
That leaves me with another question: Is constantly redrawing boundaries around culture and identity always a good thing?
3. Questions and Discussion: When Does Difference Become a Boundary?
I previously assumed that if different countries and cultures interacted more often and learned more about one another, they would naturally understand each other better and conflict would decrease. But now, I realize that being more connected and actually agreeing with one another are two very different things.
As Robertson and White emphasize, global consciousness is not global consensus. Becoming more aware of the world does not mean that people suddenly share the same values. In fact, constant comparison with other cultures can make people more conscious of their own nation, traditions, culture, and identity.
This brings me back to the question from the previous section, because I do not think drawing boundaries is necessarily negative in itself. Just as I want to keep my own personal style instead of becoming another copy of the same trend, saying, “This is something that belongs to us,” can help communities preserve their cultural identities. Being globally connected does not mean everyone has to become identical.
The problem begins when “we are different” turns into “therefore, we should be suspicious of them.” Unlike an individual’s preference for styling details, at a collective level, the desire to protect “our culture” can shift into a defensive mindset: “they are threatening what is ours.” A boundary that once helped people recognize difference can then become a wall used to exclude or reject other groups. In this way, a stronger awareness of identity can sometimes become connected to nationalism, exclusion, and cultural conflict.
The anti-globalization movement shows another interesting paradox. As Robertson and White point out, groups protesting economic globalization actively used the Internet and global networks to organize people and spread their messages. In other words, people resisting globalization were also relying on the connectivity that globalization had helped create.
For this reason, I find it difficult to see nationalism or stronger local identities simply as outside forces blocking globalization. If globalization constantly exposes people to comparisons with other societies and makes them more conscious of what is “ours,” resistance to globalization may also grow from within the process itself.
This leaves me with one final question for our class discussion:
Can nationalism and the desire to defend identity be understood simply as reactions against globalization, or can they also grow out of the connections and comparisons that globalization creates?
I do not think these two forces can be placed on completely opposite sides. Globalization is not a peaceful final stage where everyone becomes connected and conflict disappears. It seems closer to an ongoing process in which the force that connects us and the desire to recognize and preserve our differences exist at the same time.
I found your point that “the more similar we become, the more we want to be different” really interesting. I used to think globalization would make cultures across different countries more and more alike, but after reading your post, I’m not so sure. When people get exposed to more diverse cultures, they may actually care more about their own culture and identity. I also think your final question—whether nationalism can arise from the connections and comparisons brought by globalization—is worth discussing. Globalization might not make everyone identical. While it connects people, it also makes us more aware of our differences.
ReplyDelete